S+L logo

Cardinal Zen: Vatican now united in approach to China

August 11, 2011
Five minutes is a short time to explain the current diplomatic impasse between Beijing and the Vatican. When I interviewed the Bishop Emeritus of Hong Kong on the August 1st edition of Perspectives Daily, he concisely summarized the state of the relationship: it’s at a new beginning, but it may get worse before it gets better.
Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun, SDB believes the new beginning results from new leadership—and a newly unified mentality—in Rome. He described the previous approach as a strategy of “compromise”. Under its former prefect, the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples (also known as Propaganda Fide, the Vatican body in charge of missionary efforts in non-Christian countries) attempted to work with the state-controlled Church to appoint mutually-acceptable bishops. Critics say the Holy See conceded too much, whereas China refused to reciprocate by improving religious freedom.
The failure of soft diplomacy has become evident to many, in Cardinal Zen’s estimation, including the new prefect of the Propaganda Fide, Archbishop Fernando Filoni. The Cardinal is confident that, in terms of Sino-Vatican relations, the Church is now speaking with one voice. That unified position, however, has already begun to elicit a defiant reaction. Since November, the government has ordained three bishops without the Pope’s approval, with as many as forty more illicit appointments expected.
The outspoken Cardinal has many more insights regarding the situation in China. Fortunately, he has also granted an in-depth half-hour interview to Fr. Thomas Rosica, CSB for S+L’s Witness series.
Cardinal Zen offered candid answers to Fr. Rosica’s questions, including:
-Does he believe he will live to see a democratic China that respects religious freedom?
-Does he have any lines of communication with the government in mainland China, or the state-sponsored Church?
-Should visiting clergy accept invitations from the state-sponsored Church (known as the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association)?
-Has he ever feared for his life?
Watch this new Witness episode tonight to meet one of the Church’s boldest defenders of religious freedom. Witness airs at 8:00pm & midnight ET (9:00 pm PT). The episode is also streaming on demand (above).
Related posts
SLHour: Made For Love
Do gay people have a place in the Catholic Church? This week Fr. Mike Schmitz says that not only are they welcome but they belong there because we are made for love; Gillian Kantor learns something ne ...read more
Official Text of Pre-Synodal Meeting Document 2018!!
Here is the final document from the Pre-synod of Bishop 2018. These reflections were borne out of the meeting of more than 300 young representatives from around the world, convened in Rome March 19-24 ...read more
The Francis Impact in El Salvador
A reflection on The Francis Impact's experience visiting El Salvador, and their successful ban on metal mining that helped to put a stop to an environmental disaster. ...read more
Day four of the Pre-synod meetings taking place in Rome where youth from all over the world have come to talk candidly with Pope Francis about the future of the Catholic Church. The main themes from t ...read more
Oscar Romero and the legacy of Hope
(S+L Photo: TFI Director Sebastian Gomes and Cinematographer Peter Turek film in Aguilares, El Salvador on Feb 27, 2018) The crew of “The Francis Impact” traveled to El Salvador from Febru ...read more