S+L logo

CCRL 'disappointed' by Ontario prostitution ruling

March 26, 2012
On a recent episode of Catholic Focus, we tackled the issue of prostitution and the ongoing legal challenge to Ontario’s laws related to the sex trade. Today, a Court of Appeal reaffirmed parts of Justice Susan Himel’s controversial 2010 ruling that struck down three of those laws.
In summary, the court agreed with Justice Himel that the prohibitions against operating a “common bawdy house” and against “living off the avails” of prostitution were unconstitutional. The Crown may appeal, though the House of Commons may also redraft the laws in a manner that would survive a court challenge. The third law in question — communicating in public for the purposes of prostitution — was declared to be lawful, and thus remains in force.
The Catholic Civil Rights League, an intervenor in the case, expressed disappointment with the ruling. Executive director Joanne McGarry, who appears in our Catholic Focus episode, was pleased that at least one of the three laws in question will stand. However, in a statement released today, she reiterates the CCRL’s position that the “prohibition on keeping a bawdy house and living on the avails are of some assistance in preventing the exploitation of a vulnerable population.”
The CCRL hopes that the Minister of Justice will propose a new legal solution, such as one that is focused on prosecuting clients of prostitution.
Meanwhile, one of the three sex worker advocates behind the challenge could soon profit from the ruling. The Toronto Star reports that Valerie Scott is considering opening her own brothel.

Related posts

The Virgin Mary floating down a street in the Canary Islands and Pope Francis above a door in Cologne? Check out the Weekly News Round-Up. ...read more
US bishops speak openly about their feelings regarding ex-cardinal McCarrick and expectations for new sexual abuse policies - and other stories. ...read more
Pope Francis sets up a mobile health clinic for the homeless and poor in St. Peter's Square for the 2nd World Day of the Poor - and other stories. ...read more
Pope Francis announces visit to Morocco in 2019; US bishops discuss sex abuse crisis; and Archbishop Scicluna has a new post in the CDF. ...read more
Inmates from La Joya Penitentiary in Panama City are part of a special project in preparation for World Youth Day 2019 - and other stories. ...read more