S+L logo

When Popes Resign

February 13, 2013
With his announcement February 11, Pope Benedict XVI becomes one of only four popes to resign. The last time a pope resigned from the Chair of Peter was 1415, in effort to end a major schism.
The Code of Canon Laws allows for a pope to resign. The only conditions are that the decision be made freely and be publicly manifested. There is no specific person or body that must accept a pope’s resignation. Benedict XVI fulfilled these requirements, making his announcement at the end of a consistory of cardinals, in the presence of Vatican Television Cameras, ready to broadcast his announcement to the World.
The four popes who resigned from the papacy were:
-         Benedict XI
-         Gregory VI
-         Celestine V
-         Gregory VII
Benedict IX was a less than exemplary pope. He was the nephew of his two predecessors and it is said he viewed the papacy as his inheritance. He actually resigned twice, once for a large sum of money. This would have taken place around 1045.
Gregory VI was the next pope to resign in 1046 He was so disgusted with Benedict IX way of life he paid the pope to resign. However, even though Gregory VI’s election was greeted with joy, it did not bring peace to the church. Furthermore a Synod decided that the way in which he became pope was equal to simony, and convinced him that the honorable thing to do was resign.
Celestine V reigned in 1294 after only five months as Pope. He issued a solemn decree declaring that it was permissible for a pope to abdicate, and then went ahead and did so himself. He lived another two years after he resigned, and died a hermit.
Gregory VII stepped down in 1415 to put an end to the Western Schism. At the time of his resignation there were three claimants to the papacy. Gregory believed resigning would settle the question of papal succession, so convened the Council of Constance and authorized that council to elect his successor.
Pope Benedict XVI’s resignation comes after a lengthy process of discernment. The German newsite Spiegel Online spoke to the pope’s brother, Fr. Georg Ratzinger. The elder Ratzinger said his brother informed him of his decision over the summer. The elder Ratzinger said he did not offer his brother advice or try to influence his decision adding, “the responsibility is his and his alone, the decision is one he reached himself.”
* Please consider donating to Salt + Light this Lent

Related posts

Remembering Pope Benedict’s 2010 Pastoral Letter to the Catholics of Ireland
In 2010, Pope Benedict wrote a Pastoral Letter to the Catholics of Ireland on the subject of sexual abuse. Today it remains as relevant as ever. ...read more
Do You Also Wish to Go Away?
Read Fr. Thomas Rosica's reflection on the readings for the 21st Sunday in Ordinary Time. ...read more
Text of Pope Francis’ preface of Benedict’s works: A compass to Understand our Present day
Read the full text of Pope Francis’ preface of Benedict’s works: A compass to Understand our Present day. Curtesy of Aleteia Magazine. ...read more
The Final Lessons of John XXIII and Benedict XVI
The final lessons of John XXIII and Benedict XVI G.K. Chesterton once wrote: “It is of the new things that men tire… of fashions and proposals and improvements and change. It is the old th ...read more
Father Thomas Rosica: Mansbridge One on One
Father Thomas Rosica interviews CBC's Peter Mansbridge after Pope Benedict's surprise resignation & prior to the Papal Conclave that elected Pope Francis ...read more