S+L logo

Freedom to Not Have Conscience

March 9, 2015
On Friday March 6, the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario issued a press release confirming that they had dispensed with the conscience rights of their members in the province. Of course, it would be very difficult to initially conclude that, given the PR friendly title of the release: “College Council approves new policy that safeguards human rights and puts patients first.”
No amounts of spin-doctoring or media abdication of the topic can soften the thorny reality for doctors in Ontario who object to certain legal medical practices. This is of particular concern to those in the medical profession who would have objections based on their religious beliefs. No longer can they on grounds of faith or morality, refuse to give a particular prescription; no longer can they refuse to give a referral for a procedure they think is ethically wrong.
It is a dangerous precedent to set, shuffling aside the conscience rights of one individual, in order to extend some sort of privilege to another. This is especially critical when we are talking about forcing someone to do something they believe is morally and ethically wrong.
The implications are particularly worrying when you begin to think about doctors for whom faith plays an important part in their life. Canada is a country where the freedom of religion is enshrined as a pillar of society. This great tradition is a bedrock of the western world, and has allowed for the peaceful coexistence of people of different faiths. However this decision in Ontario follows a sad and increasingly common trend of freedom for some, at the expense of someone else.
There was once an understanding that pervaded society, whereby it was God that giveth and God that taketh. This is very notably associated with the rights of people, such as the right to freedom of conscience, indicating that our creator endows those rights. However the narrative today claims such powers reside in and are endowed by temporal authorities, that both giveth and taketh. Doctors in Ontario are the latest victims of this increasingly common trend.
Physicians were once required to take the Hippocratic oath, which was for centuries, the very essence of what it meant to be a healer. Today we see another hallmark of medicine fading into the winds of history. A person’s conscience and a person’s faith are undoubtedly at the core of their being. In something as critical to the care and survival of society as medicine, we must truly ask what we are giving up?
Doctors in Ontario now journey on an uncertain path, where their professional life may well come into conflict with the faith life. This is a matter where all elements of society need to engage in an honest discussion on just what that means. As people of faith, it is important that we always include ourselves in the public discourse. We can never forget our call to be a part of a culture of engagement.
Related posts
Deacon-structing Grace
A reflection for the 4th Sunday, Lent, Year B. The readings are 2 Chronicles 36:14-17a, 19-23; Psalm: 137, Ephesians 2:4-10 and John 3:14-21. Picture it: Nicodemus was a Pharisee and a religious l ...read more
Deacon-structing the Cross part 2: Making the Sign
If you’re Catholic you do it all the time. If you’re not Catholic, you probably have noticed us making this sign: right hand to our forehead, then down to our chest, then over to the left ...read more
Lent is just around the corner! The annual desert journey calls Christians back to their most intimate and essential selves as children of God. It is a time to pray, fast and give alms, insofar as the ...read more
Deacon-structing Baptism Part 3: The Ritual
Last time we concluded that Baptism welcomes us into the family of God and after Baptism we belong to God. Now let’s look at the baptism ritual. All Sacrament ritual includes three moments: anamnesi ...read more
"To take Jesus in our hands and enfold him in our arms…"
Reflection for the Feast of the Presentation of the Lord – February 2, 2018 In 1997, St. John Paul II established the special Day of Consecrated Life to coincide with the Feast of the Presentati ...read more