S+L logo

Scrambled eggs with a side of eugenics

April 20, 2010
The recent news on genetic manipulations coming out of Newcastle University (see article) is a poignant reminder of how far our culture is willing to go in the name of scientific progress—that is mix-and-matching human embryos to create one free from disease.
SAN DIEGO/EMBRYO BANKLast year similar research in the United States was conducted on monkeys and thus far had shown much promise for human application, however—as is the case in many scientific areas—researchers have put the cart before the horse.  That is, before any conclusive evidence barring long-term side-effects, researchers have decided to conduct preliminary trials on human embryos.
When I read the report last week I was initially struck by a sense of confusion, and so I scoured the internet for all articles written on the subject and upon finding several contradictions I decided to ask lead researcher Professor Doug Turnbull.   His reticent response to my email was enough to clarify my confusion, and shake my head in disbelief.
A little background
Our bodies are made of billions of cells and in each of those cells there are mitochondria—the energy producing units of cells.  Without them, good luck walking, talking, thinking or breathing.  Every single body function is dependent on these minuscule members, and just like a computer is useless without a power source so are our cells.
Genetic mutations in mitochondria can cause mild to severe diseases including: neuropathies, diabetes mellitus and deafness, and progressive vision loss, just to name a few.  By going directly to the source of the malaise—the mitochondria—Prof. Turnbull and his colleges are aiming at eliminating any future disease during development or after birth.  Who can argue with that?
The ends don’t justify the means
Unfortunately, the procedure in question involves removing the DNA of the desired individual (embryo)—containing the defective mitochondria—and placing it into another embryo, which has had its DNA removed and contains normal mitochondria.  The end result is an individual with the genes of the mother and father placed inside a donor embryo with disease-free mitochondria and removed DNA.
Are you telling me you are sacrificing one embryo—a unique member of the human family—in order to create another altered embryo?  That’s exactly what is happening, and it sounds a lot like eugenics to me.  Furthermore, it’s tantamount to killing another person for one of their organs in order to replace my dysfunctional one.
When it comes to embryonic research is seems as if anything goes.  Ultimately, the difficulty with bioethics is that what we can’t see is relegated to a position of inconsequence.  Yet, no matter what stage of development, every life is chosen and loved by God.
CNS photo/Sandy Huffaker

Related posts

Deacon-structing Sacraments | Part 1: A Sign of Grace
I guess you can’t blame Catholics if they don’t know the meaning of a Sacrament. I was a Catholic for 38 years and had received 5 of the 7 Sacraments before I really came to understand what Sacram ...read more
Read Fr. Thomas Rosica's reflection on the Broadway sensation WICKED, and it's themes of evil, redemption, friendship, and power of forgiveness. ...read more
St. Thomas More and the responsibility <br>of Christian citizenship
Read Sebastian Gomes' article on St. Thomas More, who lived in turbulent times and is a model for the Christian citizen of today. ...read more
“To set the world at naught”: <br>Thomas More, John Fisher, and the role of conscience
Read about St. Thomas More and St. John Fisher: two heroic saints who defied a tyrannical king and gave their lives rather than act against their conscience. ...read more
"I am not He, I prepare His way"
John was identified with the people of Israel, and his vocation was ultimately not only the restoration of Israel but also the conversion of the world. John was the sharp-edged sword who pointed out t ...read more
SLHour: The Real Uncle Tom
The name Josiah Henson probably doesn’t mean much to you. This week, author and film maker Jared Brock tells us about the former slave whose life story inspired Uncle Tom’s Cabin and possibly igni ...read more
Welcome to S+L’s Weekly News Round-Up. As part of my job, I come across many interesting Catholic news and stories on a daily basis. Some of them I'll cover on Perspectives Daily and the others I’ ...read more