S+L logo

September 11 and martyrdom's radicalization

September 11, 2008
From the Toronto Sun
September 11 marks the seventh anniversary of the dreadful terrorist attacks on New York, Washington and Pennsylvania.
As media attention turns again to those fateful days and to the masterminds of such acts of terror and violence, plunging the world into its current state of war and fear, I offer some considerations on the meaning of martyrdom which has become such a common, yet misunderstood, word in our vocabulary.
Those who carried out the terrorist attacks in 2001 claimed to do so "in the name of Allah" and claimed to be martyrs for a holy cause and entering into their glory.
The point isn't that Muslim suicide bombers really "are" or "are not" martyrs but rather that people revere them as martyrs, self-proclaimed or publicly, for an unholy cause.
In Islam, stories of martyrdom date back to bloodshed as the faith took root in the seventh century. It became increasingly linked to radical movements in the 20th century with calls for "martyrdom" by Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood and later with Palestinian militants and terrorist groups.
The end of the Cold War brought Christian-Muslim tensions into sharper focus, including inter-religious clashes in Indonesia and the 1996 murder of seven French monks in Algeria by Islamic militants. While such cases are always shocking, we Christians must take great care in preventing our concepts of Christian martyrdom from evolving into a counter-attack to Islamic radicals.
A martyr (in Greek: A witness) is a person who, for the Christian faith, freely and patiently suffers death at the hands of a persecutor. Martyrs choose to die rather than deny their faith by word or deed; they suffer patiently after the example of Christ; they do not resist their persecutors; they suffer death at the hand of ones who, though they may assign some other reason, really act through hatred of the Christian religion or of some Christian virtue.
DOES NOT DESIRE DEATH
The Christian martyr does not desire death nor seek it for others. The word martyr, which in the very beginning of the Christian era meant a witness of Christ, was after a while given to those alone who suffered death for the faith.
In theologies of past decades the prophetic, the radical, and the liberationist all came in for great attention. For example, Catholic priests and nuns killed for their involvement in various social justice struggles have received a great deal of attention.
However, when social justice struggles become the ideological test for the veneration of martyrs and saints, we must ask some deeper questions. We run the risk of saying that the 20th and 21st century martyrology, is a canon of the politically correct: There are martyrs, and then there are "politically interesting" martyrs.
In holding this view, there is a certain arrogance and condescension toward those who simply died for the proclamation and defence of the faith, without some further and redeeming political merit.
The era of Christian martyrdom is not something of the past. There is little disputing the fact that the 20th century, above all others, was the century of Christian martyrdom. And that phenomenon has continued into our own century.
Nevertheless, there is today a radicalization of what martyrdom means by some Christian groups. The Western world's struggle with radical Islam is creeping into views of religious martyrdom. Some Christians seem ready to embrace the connotations of "victim" and "hero" that have driven extremist Muslim declarations, with each side portraying the other faith as a persecutor.
We are living in a poisoned atmosphere or climate in which many see an Islamic siege on the entire Christian world. It is far too easy to fall into the trap of the "war of civilizations" and to misappropriate the title "martyr," thus doing a great disservice to those who truly died for giving witness to Christ and the Christian faith.

Related posts

Do You Also Wish to Go Away?
FacebookTwitter
Read Fr. Thomas Rosica's reflection on the readings for the 21st Sunday in Ordinary Time. ...read more
We can only move forward when we name the evil of clericalism
FacebookTwitter
Fr. Thomas Rosica, CSB, discusses the evils of clericalism and the path to change and healing being forged by Pope Francis. ...read more
"We all are in this boat together" : A Reflection on the Current Crisis in the Church
FacebookTwitter
Fr. Thomas Rosica, C.S.B., reflects on the current crisis in the Church, the Vatican's response, and how we can learn from this in the future. ...read more
Video Reflection on Marian Devotion
FacebookTwitter
Father Thomas Rosica, CSB, discusses the true nature and proper place for Marian devotion within the Catholic Church in this video. ...read more
A Reflection for the Solemnity of the Assumption of Mary – August 15
FacebookTwitter
Read Father Thomas Rosica's reflection on the true nature and proper place for Marian devotion within the Catholic Church. ...read more